
Nearshoring vs Offshoring: Rethinking Global Supply Chains in 2026
Nearshoring vs Offshoring: Rethinking Global Supply Chains in 2026
Friday, 23 October 2026
Why global supply chains are being restructured
The structure of global supply chains is changing faster than at any point since mass offshoring began in the 1990s. A combination of geopolitical tension, pandemic-era disruption, tariff escalation and shifting government policy has forced organisations to rethink where they source goods and how they manage supplier risk.
Kearney’s 2026 Reshoring Index surveyed CEOs across major economies and found that 75 per cent had shifted sourcing away from China to other low-cost countries (Ref 1). Only 20 per cent considered increasing domestic manufacturing. The dominant movement is not reshoring but redistribution: spreading production across a wider set of supplier countries to reduce concentration risk.
The Reshoring Initiative reported 247,000 manufacturing jobs announced through reshoring or foreign direct investment in the United States in 2025, bringing the cumulative total since 2010 to more than 2.3 million (Ref 2). Yet satisfaction among original equipment manufacturers fell from 96 per cent to 67 per cent in a single year, reflecting the gap between strategic intent and operational reality.
How nearshoring differs from offshoring
Offshoring moves production or procurement to a distant, lower-cost country. The primary driver is unit price. For decades, this meant sourcing from China, Vietnam, Bangladesh or other Asian manufacturing centres where labour costs were a fraction of domestic rates.
Nearshoring moves production closer to the end market. For a US manufacturer, this typically means Mexico or Central America. For an Australian business, it could mean Southeast Asian partners in Vietnam, Thailand or Indonesia rather than more distant suppliers in South Asia or Eastern Europe. The advantage is shorter lead times, easier oversight and reduced logistics complexity.
Reshoring brings production back to the home country entirely. Friendshoring, a newer term, describes sourcing from politically aligned nations regardless of geographic proximity. Both concepts reflect a shift from pure cost optimisation toward supply chain resilience.
What the global data shows
Kearney’s data reveals the scale of the shift away from China. Direct imports from mainland China to the United States fell by nearly one-third in 2025, a drop of $135 billion (Ref 1). The other 13 Asian low-cost countries gained $194 billion. Europe gained $62 billion. Mexico grew 8 per cent, driven largely by computer and electronics imports.
The redistribution has not translated into confidence. Only 18 per cent of CEOs surveyed by Kearney were very confident of achieving acceptable return on investment from reshoring or nearshoring, down from 47 per cent the prior year (Ref 1). More than half said tariffs had made nearshoring less attractive. Policy uncertainty was cited as the primary challenge by 57 per cent of respondents.
Labour is a binding constraint. Among surveyed CEOs, 55 per cent reported difficulty finding workers for production lines while 61 per cent faced shortages in technical roles (Ref 1). Manufacturing employment in the United States fell from 12.8 million to 12.6 million between 2024 and 2025. These gaps limit how quickly companies can bring production closer to home, regardless of strategic intent.
Mexico’s nearshoring boom shows signs of strain. Industrial construction fell 30 per cent in the final quarter of 2025 while GDP growth slowed to 0.8 per cent. Geopolitical risk became the top driver for contract manufacturers’ customers, rising from 24 per cent to 44 per cent in a single year (Ref 2).
Australia’s exposure and response
A Proxima survey of more than 500 CEOs across five countries found that 59 per cent of Australian leaders expect serious operational impact within three weeks of a supply chain disruption, compared to 51 per cent globally (Ref 3). One in five Australian businesses would fail within two weeks, nearly double the global average of 14 per cent.
The country’s geographic isolation compounds the problem. Australia ranks last among OECD developed nations for manufacturing self-sufficiency (Ref 4). Manufacturing contributes roughly 6 per cent of GDP. Over 60 per cent of manufacturers experienced delays in essential materials in 2024, according to the Australian Industry Group (Ref 5).
Government policy is responding. The $15 billion National Reconstruction Fund supports growth in critical minerals and clean energy manufacturing (Ref 5). The federal government’s Buy Australia plan aims to redirect government contracts toward domestic suppliers (Ref 4). A survey of Australian manufacturers found that 55 per cent planned to bring operations back to Australia, citing pandemic-era volatility and geopolitical tensions (Ref 4).
Total cost of ownership in sourcing decisions
The choice between nearshoring and offshoring is rarely as simple as comparing unit prices. A component manufactured offshore may cost 30 per cent less at the factory gate but become more expensive once logistics, customs duties, quality inspection, inventory holding costs and intellectual property risk are factored in.
The Reshoring Initiative’s analysis of 190 sourcing cases comparing China and the United States illustrates the point. On unit price alone, the US won only 8 per cent of comparisons. When total cost of ownership was applied, the win rate rose to 32 per cent. With a 15 per cent tariff included, it reached 46 per cent (Ref 2). Price comparison alone consistently understates the true cost of distant sourcing.
For Australian organisations, the calculation differs from the US context but the principle holds. Nearshoring to Southeast Asia offers shorter shipping times than sourcing from South Asia or Africa but may involve higher unit costs than the cheapest global options. The decision depends on the category. Commodities with stable specifications may tolerate longer supply lines while complex or time-sensitive components benefit from regional proximity.
Building procurement capability for complex sourcing decisions
As supply chains grow more complex, procurement professionals need sharper tools for evaluating sourcing alternatives. The choice between nearshoring and offshoring is ultimately a risk management decision that requires structured analysis of cost, quality, lead time, geopolitical exposure and supplier capability.
AcademyGlobal’s Procurement Risk Management course provides the frameworks for identifying, assessing and mitigating risks across supply chains, including the geopolitical and logistical factors that shape sourcing decisions. For professionals working through the financial analysis behind sourcing strategy, the Cost Modelling in Procurement course develops the skills to build total cost of ownership models that capture the full expense of each sourcing option.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between nearshoring and offshoring?
Offshoring movesproduction to a distant lower-cost country, typically to reduce unit costs. Nearshoring moves production to a country closer to the end market, reducing lead times and logistics complexity. Both are sourcing strategies, but nearshoring prioritises proximity while offshoring prioritises cost.
Is reshoring replacing offshoring?
Not at scale. While reshoring announcements have increased significantly, most companies are redistributing production across multiple lower-cost countries rather than bringing manufacturing home. Kearney’s 2026 data shows that 75 per cent of CEOs shifted sourcing away from China to other low-cost nations rather than to domestic production.
Why is Australia particularly vulnerable to supply chain disruption?
Australia’s geographic isolation creates longer supply lines than most developed economies. The country ranks last among OECD nations for manufacturing self-sufficiency. A Proxima survey found that 59 per cent of Australian leaders expect serious operational impact within three weeks of disruption, compared to 51 per cent globally.
What is total cost of ownership in procurement?
Total cost of ownership captures all costs associated with a sourcing decision, not just the purchase price. It includes logistics, customs duties, quality control, inventory holding, lead time variability, intellectual property risk and compliance costs. TCO analysis often narrows or eliminates the apparent price advantage of distant suppliers.
How do tariffs affect nearshoring decisions?
Tariffs change the cost equation by adding direct costs to imports from specific countries. However, Kearney’s 2026 survey found that more than half of CEOs said tariffs had made nearshoring less attractive by raising costs across multiple sourcing locations. The net effect depends on which countries face tariffs and at what rates.
References
- Kearney, 2026 Reshoring Index
- Trade and Industry Development, The Next Wave of Reshoring (Reshoring Initiative Data)
- Consultancy.com.au, Proxima: Australian Companies Highly Vulnerable to Supply Chain Shocks
- SYSPRO Australia, Onshoring Australian Manufacturing
- Australian Manufacturing, Australian Manufacturing in 2025: Challenges and Pathways to Progress